Skip to main content

Rethinking cell phones in education - LIBE 477B Reflection on mobile devices and libraries


http://ajjuliani.com/can-honest-conversation-phones-classroom/
No Cell Phones Allowed!  As educators, we've all internally (or maybe even externally) rolled our eyes at how addicted students seem to be with their phones.  Perhaps we need to be more open-minded about smart devices in schools.  While smartphones can often be a distraction, they can also be used effectively in the classroom.  I've begun to allow and even encourage the use of personal smart devices in my classes.  I am very clear with students that I do allow them to use their phones, but only for educational purposes.  Personal smart devices have become more frequently used in my classroom for several reasons, the most essential being that educators have to encourage students to develop 21st century digital literacies, and this is difficult without the digital part.  While I would love to teach in a 1-1 environment (meaning each student has a laptop or tablet issued by the school), this wasn't realistic for the financial situation of my former school district. While my previous school had very little available technology within the school (2 computer labs for 1700 students), the school wifi was freely available to students.  Because the school wifi meant students didn't have to use their own data, I was able to use a BYOD or "bring your own device" policy for times when students needed to use technology in their learning.  While the BYOD policy worked in my classroom, I did have concerns regarding equitable access as I did teach in an inner-city school and some students did not have smartphones.

As we all know, mobile devices are ubiquitous in western nations, and their prevalence in developing nations is increasing.   In an article for The Guardian, Alison Flood cited a 2014 Unesco study on the "mobile reading revolution" happening in developing nations as demonstrating that "mobile reading represents a promising, if still under-utilized, pathway to text."  The impact of mobile reading devices  on improving literacy in developing nations cannot be understated; the Unesco study author Mark West maintains that phones "can help people develop, sustain and enhance literacy skills."  Mobile devices are essential to encouraging literacy skills in developing world populations because it is so much more cost effective and more readily available than print resources; the Unesco study points out that this information technology is so important because "they are plentiful in places where books are scarce."

While mobile phone technology has the potential to be a "library in one's pocket," and many people in developing nations do have cell phones, many of these cell phones are not smartphones but so-called "dumb phones."  Deanne Gittens' 2016 blogpost "Basic Cell Phones Still Rule in Developing Countries" points out that the best-selling mobile phone in the world is the Nokia 1100, which is a basic phone rather than a smart phone.  There are many reasons that people in developing nations may not choose to purchase a smartphone, including the cost and the fact that data is an expensive commodity that becomes "non-essential in rural areas where some families live on a daily budget of what amounts to the cost of a Starbucks coffee."  Still, Gittens notes that this is changing with companies such as Huawei beginning to market inexpensive smartphones in Africa that are directed at the growing middle class.

Importantly, non-profit organizations such One Laptop Per Child are looking to provide children in developing nations with access to rugged, low-cost, low-power connected laptops.  The initiative provides children with laptops to improve literacy and numeracy skills so that they may "break the cycle of poverty and empower children to create a better future for themselves and their families."
one.laptop.org

The mission to find ways to improve literacy and education in developing nations is also the focus of BRCK which provides a laptop kit to impoverished areas of Nairobi.  Steven Livingston in his article on "Classroom technologies narrow education gap in developing nations" describes the BRCK Kio kit as  40 Kio tablets that come with a BRCK- "a durably built, brick-sized connectivity device intended for use where electricity and internet connections are unreliable."  Both One Laptop Per Child and BRCK seek to make local, culturally relevant educational content available to children in even remote and poverty-stricken areas.

Though the focus of many non-profits is on developing nations, there is an argument that some remote First Nations communities in Canada could benefit from better access to technology to improve education.  Many socio-economically disadvantaged First Nations communities lack access to education that is equal to that provided by the province, and many students in small and remote communities are faced with the choice of leaving their reserves to pursue education in urban centres, far away from their families.  Brian Beaton's article "Digital Technology Innovations in Eduction in Remote First Nations" highlights the work being done by First Nations leaders and educators across the North who are using digital tools and networks to support education and training programs that best meet the needs of the community.  Not only are these students engaging in 21st century learning, they don't need to leave the safety of their community to do so.  Making access to technology a possibility for First Nations children on Canadian reserves is just as life-transforming as making smart devices available to children living in developing nations.

Smart devices have the potential to transform learning in both developed and developing nations.  In western nations, technology can enhance learning and encourage the development of 21st literacy skills, while in developing nations, smart devices in the hands of children has the potential to provide an education where there was previously little chance for one.


References

Beaton, Brian. "Digital Technology Innovations in Education in Remote First Nations." In Education.  Vol.22, No.1, 2016. https://ineducation.ca/ineducation/article/view/266/847

Flood, Alison. "Mobile reading revolution takes off in developing world." The Guardian. Wed. 23 April 2014. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/apr/23/mobile-reading-revolution-unesco-study-phones-africa-subcontinent

Gittens, Deanne. "Basic cell phones still rule in developing countries." Hyla blog. Nov 29, 2016. http://blog.hylamobile.com/basic-cell-phones-still-rule-in-developing-countries

Livingston, Steven. "Classroom technologies narrow education gap in developing nations." Blogpost. Tuesday August 23, 2016. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2016/08/23/classroom-technologies-narrow-education-gap-in-developing-countries/

One Laptop Per Child.  http://one.laptop.org

Unicef Innovation. Blogpost. "How Mobile Phones are Changing the Developing World." 5 August 2015. https://blogs.unicef.org/innovation/how-mobile-phones-are-changing-the-developing-world/



Comments

  1. Great post! So much information. I have also struggled with students using their phones in the classroom. You said you are encouraging it more, what methods are you using to make sure the time using the phone is productive? I love technology and have encouraged it but found sometimes it depended on the class itself whether it was productive or not. I am always looking for new ways to make it better.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I Knew It All Along... Didn't I?- LIBE 477B Reflection on Past Teacher-Librarian Topics

A partner was cheating. A comeback to win the last period in a hockey game. Trump shockingly wins the presidency. Each situation may be unique, but we have often heard ourselves say, "I knew it all along." The tendency to feel like we knew it all along, though we actually didn't, is what psychologists refer to as hindsight bias. http://neologisms.blogs.wm.edu/2016/04/18/hindsight-bias/ As an educator, I've experienced hindsight bias in believing that I was always aware of important issues in education.  "Of course, I've alway know it's important to incorporate more technology and help students develop necessary digital skills." "Obviously, blogging encourages deeper reflection and allows for an authentic audience for writing." "Naturally, I know how to design effective and engaging professional development opportunities." I could say that I was aware of these issues all along as they seem so obvious now, but they weren't

The final frontier: Engaging and useful professional development - LIBE477 Reflection on meeting the ICT needs of teachers

To boldly go where no educator has gone before. Image from Know Your Meme Teacher-librarians have always been the vanguard of teaching Information and Communication Technology (ICT) skills, helping colleagues to integrate new technologies into classrooms and guiding our students toward becoming digitally literate citizens.  The wonderful teacher-librarians I've worked with (shout out to Joanne and Katherine!) were always so generous with their time and effort to help those of us lacking a technological skillset.  Because I lacked confidence with my technological prowess, when I became interested in using infographics as a way to demonstrate students' knowledge rather than the traditional research paper or poster presentation, they helped me to create lessons on the skills needed to create infographics, including researching, citing, summarizing and using infographic websites that allows one to design an original infographic. Working with my school's teacher-librari

Blog love- LIBE 477B Reflection on supporting my professional learning

The assignments and discussions in this course have already been an invaluable resource for me; I've gained some valuable technology skills that I can use in my classroom/library, and I've gained some valuable insight reading the discussion posts and blog posts of my co-learners in this class. Fellow educators in this class have made important points in blogposts and discussion board comments that I didn't previously consider regarding technology and digital literacy, including concerns about student privacy and the dangers of being "too connected."   Image from https://ncccelearning.com/learning-modules/using-blogs-to-support-your-instruction/ Thanks to the tutorial on using Feedly , I'll be able to continue to follow education blogs of interest.  When I first began reading education blogs, I used Google Reader; when that service was discontinued I began to use Flipboard to keep up with favourite news sites and blogs. While l really like Flipboar